Label: Chappell Recorded Music Library - CAL 4004 • Series: Chappell International Series • Format: Vinyl LP • Country: UK • Genre: Electronic, Jazz, Pop, Classical, Stage & Screen • Style: Space-Age, Neo-Classical, Novelty, Experimental, Easy Listening
Thus, my progression went from bipolar solid-state to tube to MOSFET, with a wide spread of sonic characteristics between them: stygian bass from the Adcom; uncanny spatial presentation and vocal reproduction from the VTLs; and an overall superior sound from the Muse.
The external appearance of the SA is conservative and simple, the brushed black silver is also available front panel simply carrying the on-off switch and the status LED; this last glows red at turn-on, green once all systems are go.
It takes a full minute for the LED to change from green to red; as with traffic lights, this is one of the longer minutes you'll encounter. The back panel sports gold-plated binding posts and RCA jacks, as well as the nonremovable AC line cord. I have a problem with the size of this cord; 18ga cable may suffice for preamps and CD players many designers would opt for a heavier gauge even with these line-level componentsbut I feel that the power-line cord of a power amplifier, especially one rated as powerful as the SA, should be larger for better current delivery to the power supply.
In comparison, both the Adcom and Sumo Polaris have Counterpoint - The Boneschi Electronic Combo - Sounds Electronic AC line cords, with half again as much conductor diameter. The Muse comes supplied with a hefty 10ga AC cable. Removing the top cover revealed a most impressive interior; parts quality, layout, and construction were all superb.
Wima metallized-polypropylene and Wonder caps, Resista metal-film resistors, and several small-value polystyrenes populate the circuit board. Since both rectifier bridges are fed by People Aint No Good - The Cramps - Take Me Alive SA's single power transformer, I guess the power supply can't be considered dual-mono by those totalitarian separatists who insist upon complete isolation between channels, and frown upon using the same Q-tip to clean both ears.
An interesting aspect of the SA's design is the material used for its chassis: copper-plated steel. In the promotional literature and owner's manual, Counterpoint makes much of the contribution of this unique chassis material to the overall sound quality, due to the copper plating shorting out Rantaregee - One More Reggae For The Road - Anita Hirvonen - Parhaat current-induced hysteresis distortion of the steel.
The Counterpoint's hybrid circuit uses two 6DJ8 dual-triodes per channel for its input and driver stages. The SA's tubes are Counterpoint's own selected parts; according to the owner's manual, every tube that leaves the factory in an amp or preamp has had over hours of burn-in and 35 individual tests and measurements. As used in the SA, voltage amplification is derived from the two sections of a 6DJ8 configured in a cascaded common-cathode arrangement.
Local feedback is used to improve linearity, and global feedback is returned to the cathode resistor from the first stage of the Pentasonic (Mix 2) - Sounds Unlimited - Pentasonic driver stage, this consisting of one section of the second 6DJ8, the other section serving as its current source.
Counterpoint feels that using a section of the 6DJ8 as a current source achieves better linearity than the more common resistor-loaded topology. Counterpoint states that these devices are biased to a very high standing current; I can definitely attest to this, as the amp ran extremely hot even during idle; with music material, the heatsinks were too hot to leave my hand on.
In the Counterpoint SA we have a well-built circuit using selected tubes in a high-linearity topology for the delicate input and driver sections, right where we want tubes to be for their superior voltage amplification abilities; MOSFETs in the output section, devices that combine the sound of tubes with the current drive of solid-state, biased heavily into class-A; the finest passive components available in Wonder and Wima film caps and Resista high-quality resistors; heavy copper pcb traces, good layout, superb construction; and even the chassis is all-out, its copper-plated steel designed to improve the sound beyond that which the exact same circuit would achieve in a steel Around The World - Dry Law - Synthetic Angels aluminum box.
So why did it sound so bad? I wasn't prepared for this. I mean, I was really expecting something special from the Counterpoint; everything about its design and construction points toward superlative sound. Counterpoint's flagship SA-4 amplifier has an excellent reputation, as do the various Counterpoint preamps.
If ever a product had a background of sonic excellence, it was this one, but I absolutely could not believe how flawed the SA sounded, from top to bottom. The amp had been left on continuously for a couple of days before I listened to it, but with no music playing; in order to give it the benefit of the doubt, I put the soundtrack to Superfly footnote 1 on infinite repeat Counterpoint - The Boneschi Electronic Combo - Sounds Electronic leaving for work the next Aman Adanalı - Various - Turistik Oyun Havaları. When I came home that evening, I wiped my mental slate clean and listened to the Counterpoint again.
No difference. Ten straight hours of "Freddy's Dead" and "Junkie Chase Instrumental " hadn't improved a thing besides my mailman's day. Where to begin?
The bass was boomy and distorted, with extremely poor pitch definition. The Counterpoint rendered the low end as a separate, disconnected entity from the rest of the music; without the bassline implying movement, music lacked the tension and release so vital to the emotional ebb and flow that must be there for my monkey bone footnote 2 to vibrate.
The midrange was the least satisfying I have heard from any amplifier in a long time. Vocals came across as harsh and congested, with a throaty coloration apparent on both male and female voice. On the Trinity SessionMargo Timmins's ultra-clear voice sounded gravelly and dry, almost as if the Cowboy Junkies were suddenly fronted by Koko Taylor footnote 3.
The midrange and high end shared the most amusical characteristic of the SA a hard spittiness that laid a halo of hash over everything.
This was not a subtle effect; it rendered even my favorite discs unlistenable. The high end of the Counterpoint was bright, grainy, and painful to listen to at any but the lowest volume levels. Brother Ray's piano bless Tom Dowd, again was miked from a good distance and sounded that way with the Muse. The Counterpoint added a tinkly quality to the piano that sounded very unnatural.
In addition, Connie Kay's brushed hi-hat, normally very much in the background and softly rendered, became harsh Counterpoint - The Boneschi Electronic Combo - Sounds Electronic distracting. The Counterpoint - The Boneschi Electronic Combo - Sounds Electronic was very similar to the infamous Aphex "Aural Exciter" footnote 4 circuit so abused by many pop producers, and one which never fails to set my teeth grinding. I can listen to dull, sterile amps all day long, but the SA was so irritating in so many different ways that I dreaded my sessions with it during the month and a half I had to evaluate it.
After swapping cables, lifting the ground pin, changing the AC polarity, changing the absolute polarity, anything to get it to sound decent, I Counterpoint - The Boneschi Electronic Combo - Sounds Electronic to give the SA my Ultimate Test; I lit the five Make Love To Me - June Christy - Ballads For Night People candles in the shrine, said a silent prayer, and slowly placed Elvis's Sun Sessions RCA CD R into the player.
Most music-lovers have several records they call their favorites, in no particular order. Everything else comes in a distant second. Suffice it to say, if any CD was going to sing to me through the Counterpoint, it was going to Ive Got The World On A String - Nancy Harrow - Wild Women Dont Have The Blues Sun Sessions. Oh my God in Heaven Bill Black's doghouse slap-bass sounded like a tuba along with someone playing the spoons on their knee, and Scotty Moore's guitar solos had a stridency I know isn't on the CD.
But worst of all, Elvis's vocals became harsh and steely, with distorted sibilance and that throaty coloration I mentioned earlier. I still can't quite believe it even now, but for the first time everI couldn't listen much more than halfway through "Blue Moon of Kentucky"; the Counterpoint's time was definitely up. Conclusion Reading this review, one is mightily tempted to discount it outright; no amp could be that bad.
Surely I exaggerate, perhaps put off sufficiently by one or two areas of weakness to dump on the whole spectrum of performance. Unfortunately, that's not the case here. I'll leave a conditional opening here, as I find it hard to believe any established high-end manufacturer would let something this flawed out the door. I suspect that something is very much amiss inside this amplifier; if it's defective or broken in any way, then I would welcome the chance to hear a properly functioning unit.
But if the amp I listened to represents a fully functioning SA, approved by Counterpoint as a sterling example of their line, then I can't possibly recommend it for music listening.
Footnote 1: Curtom Cur. One of my all-time favorites and probably not in stock at your local music emporium, so call Ichiban Records at to order a copy. On a sadder note, Superfly 's composer, soul great Curtis Mayfield, was paralyzed by a falling lighting rig at a concert last year. He is reportedly doing well, but it looks like the paralysis is permanent. Footnote 2: The monkey bone is the structure that encompasses the spine, skull, and hip-bone. As there is a wide variation among monkey-bone resonant frequencies between different people, so is there a wide variation in musical tastes.
Footnote 3: Now there's a visual Footnote 4: An Aphex "Aural Exciter" is, pure and simple, a distortion generator. It takes the incoming audio and generates a second signal comprised of low-order harmonic distortion, which is then mixed back with the original audio, the ratio of course being adjustable by the "Excitement" knob on the front panel.
And they called Caligula mad. I think that this review is totally misleading or something caused this. I have been very happy with counterpoint sa for years.
It is excellent as well as counterpoint sa Search form Search. Solid State Power Amp Reviews. Log in or register to post comments. Related Latest Galleries Recommended. Schiit Audio Aegir power amplifier. Dynaco Stereo transistor power amplifier. CH Precision M1. Verity Audio Monsalvat Amp power amplifier. McIntosh Laboratory MC power amplifier.
Carver Silver Seven-t monoblock power amplifier. First Watt SIT-3 power amplifier. Luxman M power amplifier. Constellation Performance Centaur II power amplifier. Mytek Brooklyn Amp power amplifier. Threshold T power amplifier. Moon by Simaudio monoblock power amplifier. Pass Laboratories XA Carver Research Lightstar Reference power amplifier. Recording of January Munich Elac Carina BS Benchmark LA4 line preamplifier. Slow Listening.
Christmas in New Orleans Via Cologne. Rocktron CS 5. Great American Sound Thaedra preamplifier. Fidelity Research FR-1 Mk. The Clash: Still Calling.
BurakA's system. Counterpoint - The Boneschi Electronic Combo - Sounds Electronic Audio Counterpoint - The Boneschi Electronic Combo - Sounds Electronic Room My stereo setup.
Entrance Of The Emperior And His Court - Zoltán Kodály / The London Symphony Orchestra / István Kert, Kriv Sam - Sing Sing Singers - Sing Sing Singers, Les 90 Maçons (Inédit) - Tri Yann - En Concert, Frontschwein - Various - Gebrüll Für Müll - Mülltausch CD, Various - Trance House 3